New India, old violence - First Cut

New India, old violence

Priya Ramani - Thursday, February 26, 2009 12:13 PM
Yesterday I woke up to a page (click on page3) full of violence in Hindustan Times. A 27 year-old man smashed the head of a one and a half year old boy because the child touched his new parked Bajaj Discover motorcycle; a 19-year-old boy was stabbed to death by four friends because they had an argument; and a 22-year-old man was stabbed 18 times when he was out wedding shopping.

All three events happened in Delhi so one would be tempted to go on about how dangerous this city is. Then I read Stephen Alter's horrific account of being attacked in his Mussoorie home in the latest issue of Outlook magazine.

Still north India, one could argue.

Then I read about the Dalit youngster who was lynched for something to do with an upper caste girl (it's still unclear). This horror occurred a few hours away from Mumbai.

Then there's the wretched Delhi-Gurgaon Expressway which, I'm convinced, is going to beat the Blueline bus as the biggest "on road" killer in Delhi--around 90 people have died here since the Expressway opened in February 2008.

Yet we use the public debate space to discuss why we are irritated with the made up word Slumdog and the antics of the Shri Ram Sene.  
Share this post: email it! | del.icio.us! | digg it! | newsVine!

From V.B.N.Ram

February 26, 2009 6:47 PM
The Indian ethos, coupled with its spirit of tolerance, by and large, instills values which are repugnant to the cult of violence. However, the modern world, is intensely violence prone. The countries bordering India, notably Pakistan, Bangladesh, Mynmar and Nepal, with whom India has porus borders, are breeding grounds for terrorism, trafficking in arms and drugs and counterfeiting and laundering of money. The extent of crime and its proliferation, are at an all time high, because of lack of initiative and enthusiasm among citizens to find remedial measures, as well as a virtually non-existent homeland security. Our counter-crime mechanics, must be more tech savvy and we should not be hesitate to keep abreast with the latest advances in this area. As far as city crime goes, armed desperados, have learnt from experience, that post the crime, which are committed with complete lack of fear and total impunity, they can vanish into thin air, even before the police can come within their sniffing reach.

From Sumita

February 27, 2009 1:47 PM
Read Tarun Tejpal's The Story of My Assassins and any illusions about 'spirit of tolerance' will shatter. Truly heartbreaking. We continue to live in a make-belief world.

From V.B.N.Ram

February 28, 2009 11:05 AM
I generally, like to avoid getting embroiled in cross-blog controversies. However. I was proved by the above blog from Sumita. Tarun Tejpal's experiences are sad, but they are no reflection of how the vast majority of people in India ( cutting across religious and regional barriers, relate to each other. Let us not overlook the fact, that India's demographic profile is a molotov cocktail ( petrol and explosive mix bomb ) sort. And such a mix, should, in any other nation have set the nation on flames, but is this happening in India ? Clearly No. Look at Pakistan, it is the worst kind of theocracy. Fundamentalists have, since its creation intermittantly raised the bogey " Islam is in danger and therefore the government of the day, needs unreserved and uneqivocal support. Yet the ruling governments of the day have got anything , but such support. Look at Banladesh, the radicals , or the ultra-liberals, the likes of Taslima Nasreem , are being hounded. Look at the coup , in that nation, which is making the ruling dispensation to helplessly relent to the unreasonable and irrational demands of BDR. Look at Nepal, which has dispensed with the monarchy, but its vast majotity of population both in towns and villages has still not reconciled with the Maoists. Ditto for Myanmar, where the Nobel Laurate Ang san Suchi, is unable to dislodge the military dictatorship. Sumita, let me tell you India has survived with democracy, only due to its " spirit of tolerance " If you need any further proof of this, please see a story on Page 8 of the Times of India of Feb 28, 2009- covered in the Times City page with the caption reading " Hindu girl brought luck to Muslim parents. The history of post-independent India , right from the days of the partition, is replete with such emotive occurances. Conceded, we most certainly, need to improve our shabby track record relating to the lack of cohesiveness within our multi-cultural, multi-ethnic , multi lingual melting pot

From Ravi

March 16, 2009 2:12 PM
Delhi Gurgaon Expressway

POST YOUR COMMENT

:
(required)
 
Email Address
(required)
   
(optional)
(HTML not allowed)