Confessions of a South Mumbai voter - First Cut

Confessions of a South Mumbai voter

Priya Ramani - Thursday, April 30, 2009 6:56 PM

It's quite clear now that voter turnout in South Mumbai will be even less than it was in 2004.

Surely after 26/11 these people could have got their act together, you must be wondering. These bloody South Mumbai types. All prime-time talk and no action, right?

Before I continue, I have a confession to make (god I feel like I'm in at an AA meeting): Hi I'm Priya, a resident of South Mumbai and I didn't vote.

So am I the classic couldn't-care-less South Mumbai voter then?

In 2004 I voted Milind Deora. He won. The time before I voted Congress too.

In 2009, I was set to vote for Deora. My parents did. They made a day of it. They woke up early, went for a morning walk, voted (there were only four other voters at the booth) and had breakfast out. My father loves Sonia Gandhi. He would bear any inconvenience for her.

"South Mumbai turnout is only 11% so far. Go out and vote people," a friend pleaded earlier today on Facebook. The final voter turnout is around 43%, and that's some percentage points lower than last year.

Yet, I didn't vote. Why?

These days I live in Delhi. In the span of two months I needed to make three trips to Bombay--my dad's 70th birthday, a good friend's wedding, and a vote for Milind Deora. For reasons irrelevant here, I could only travel twice. I thought really long about which of these events was most important to me. I knew my father would consider it a 70th birthday gift if I voted instead of just hung out with him on his birthday.

Besides, poor Milind Deora campaigned so hard, harder than he ever has. He was regularly at Marine Drive talking to voters (he met my parents too). Surely he deserved my support?

But I couldn't shake off the image of Vilasrao Deshmukh, the Congress chief minister, taking Bollywood director Ramgopal Varma for a tour of the Oberoi, after the hotel was gutted by terrorists last November.

Then again, I believe the BJP and Shiv Sena are parochial, conservative, anti-women, scum parties. And there's no way I'm going to vote for a party that lists building a mandir in its election manifesto.

As I was thinking about these things, Manmohan Singh and LK Advani continued to bicker about irrelevant issues. Say something about the girl child, I wanted to tell them. Say something about the security personnel who died in the Naxalite attacks during election month, I thought. Instead, we had a national debate on gudiya vs budhiya.

That's when I decided the Congress would have to do without me.

It's easy to travel on Delhi's broad roads and live in its Lutyens bungalows and vote. Before asking why Mumbai hasn't voted ask what political parties have done for the city. If you lived in dirty, grimy, overcrowded, overworked Mumbai and you had to pick between voting and taking your family on a well-deserved summer vacation, you might pick the latter too.

 

 

 

Share this post: email it! | del.icio.us! | digg it! | newsVine!

From Talented Idiot

April 30, 2009 7:34 PM
There were people other than Mr. Deora and the Shiv Sena candidate you know.... For one, there was this Meera Sanyal ... The idea is to make your voice heard ... even if you vote for someone who might not win, you make a point by adding one more vote to the account of a candidate you believe in ... and my friend, it seems to me that you really have not looked beyond 2 candidates ... I'm sorry, but you have nothing but a bad excuse... But to come all the way from Delhi to vote is a bit too much anyway :) Cheers.

From ravi g

April 30, 2009 8:06 PM
I regretted that I had to return from India just a week before voting began. Though I could not vote as do not any more hold election/voting card. Yet I would have extended my visit if I was elegible to vote (even at the daily cost of 5 figure rupees I get). But indeed 17 hrs of Delhi to Mumbai is more cumbersome than 8 hrs of London to Delhi. Or is it just a lame excuse.

From ajay

April 30, 2009 8:38 PM
Peopple like you are the biggest hypocrates and ansd selfish. The biggest communalist in this country are the so called secularist for whom one who critcises his hindu religion can only be secular. When ever people like you use the word "secular" and chant Babri Maszid, thousand of broken tamples and vulgerises statues, burnt libraries, coversion with sword instantly start troubling my mind. Was Babri an answer for that? Not at all. It was absolutely stupid. But then who are you to pontificate on that and keep synically reminding the Hindus that some out of them destroyed Babri Maszid. You never say with same breath what destruction muslims heaped on this country. You are as good a moralist goon as those who attacked pubs, they put on saffron colour and you the secular shreds. Can you please allow the hindus and the muslim of this country some peace. In the name of secularism you have had this country for a good ride for last sixty years. The mention of temple by a party in Ayodhya is their democratic right. I am against making a temple by destruction of a mosque. But if you insist on restoration of mosque, well you will have to restore millions of tamples. Mind you,I am in for making a tample. That is what secularism is all about. Secularism is acknowlwdging the existence and rights of other religion and not doing a fentastic reserch as to Hindus being cow eaters.

From Concerned Mumbaikar

April 30, 2009 8:45 PM
Ms Priya, Its terribly disappointing that a Mumbai-lover (as apparent from ur Lounge edits) and a popular writer like you is near-proud of not voting in an election where everyone's eyes were on South Mumbai. Your piece here has more reasons to vote than not to vote, so its probably your guilt which is doing the talking. What more reasons than Milind and Meera do you need to vote? Sorry to advise, but you have lost the right to talk about the pains of Mumbai (esp the Mumbai south of Worli) in your edits. If in the future, you are found critical of the traffic on Pedder road, you shall be only called a hypocrite. I guess your sentiment echoes that of a SOBO voter who must've lazed out the day in their PRADA swimwear at CCI club or Goa. I guess you guys need a dozen more Kasabs to shove bullets into your loved ones' heads to wake up and take the first steps towards a more secure city. Thanks for making me lose respect and love for you, A Lounge Reader (who voted) PS: Did Samar vote?

From Tanvi Surti

April 30, 2009 8:51 PM
You sound like the typical South Mumbaiite - woe betide me, I am the victim, so what is the point in voting? I think it is ironical you talk about South Mumbaiites don't care enough, 11% voter turnout etc... why would you judge other people if you yourself did not take the trouble to vote? Deciding between going to a party and exercising your civic right, ah the dilemma! Ofcourse, you want to go to the party. Because all politicians are crooks and it doesn't matter who you vote for or not. What about Meera Sanyal? Do you realize that your vote in South Mumbai could have brought a candidate who could make a difference into office? Not only does everything you say is cliched, I feel that you love playing the victim. Furthermore, you write about it like it is all an amusing story. For future reference - if you didn't vote, don't complain about the state of the country.

From Me Mumbaikar

April 30, 2009 8:56 PM
I second Concerned Mumbaikar It's a shame tht u did not vote..n u seem to b very proud of it

From Anushka Shah

April 30, 2009 9:05 PM
Stay away from Mumbai.

From Shoba Narayan

April 30, 2009 9:13 PM
I don't think she is proud of it. I think she is stating the facts-- and easing her conscience.

From i am not murli deora's son

April 30, 2009 10:14 PM
(m)adam's family party pls gimme a ticket like u did for murli deora's son i am a good worker and will regularly show up at marine drive during elections my father and mother like you because u are from the first political family also we also like the young rahul baba because in an anarchy he is the crown prince bjp and ss work only on stupid issues and didnot work anything constructive like except reviving the economy and eliminating current account and capital account deficits which the (m)adam's pary revived when it again came back to power but we are educated,we are young and we like fun, who cares! stop publishing such stupid articles mint! take my word for it!

From Tunali

April 30, 2009 10:36 PM
Thats some example you set. Can't imagine you're justifying it. People like you give us South Bombayites a bad name!

From Ritesh

April 30, 2009 11:39 PM
we make boundaries in our heads, we divide a small island into north, south , west and what not, so when trains are bombed its not the south's problem, when hotels get attacked, the northies come and take pictures. it's good to be angry, but i guess its lame to not vote. every country has its own share of issues, milind deora is as bad as a priya dutt or a raj thackeray or a mayawati who is as bad as most other candidates, not all...they only come to u when its election time, what matters is how many times do we grab their throats, do we go to them when we have bad roads, or floods, we just expect them to show up and work on their own, power corrupts, and they suffer from the same disease when they get the chair, it took a slap in behrampada for sunil dutt to mend his ways to some extent, and i can only slap and try to straighten my candidate when i have some blue ink on my middle finger...40 percent of the country is illiterate...and they are the ones who vote, mostly on caste and class grounds, or their votes are bought, the rest 60 choose to act funny, some of em vote some of em don't, so we get a government selected by illiterates and fanatics...its their bunch of fools that make a mockery of the electoral process and tragic events like 26/11...am sure your precious vote would have made some difference, atleast it would have empowered you and me to walk into deora's office and slap him if the need be

From ankur kakkar

April 30, 2009 11:58 PM
hey ma'am, i can quite understand your viewpoint and i have written a similar 3 part series on my blog .. we are always left to choose the least worst option.. please read : http://ankurkakkar.blogspot.com/2009/03/why-i-will-not-vote-this-general.html , if and when you find time. thanx.

From Kunal Purohit

May 1, 2009 1:38 AM
Hi Ma'am. Reading quite a few of your Lounge edits, I could come to the inference that I end up agreeing with you and share sensibilites with you on most issues. However, this one post has managed to change that b'cuz this is where I strongly disagree with you. Being a first-time voter,I could feel a sense of participation and pride as the wet ink tapered down my finger. This time alleast, I told myself, I would be able to walk in pride at the fact that our city would have finally shaken off the reputation of being apathetic to politics and policy-making alike and that our city would record a high turnout. Out of all constituencies, yours atleast, as some one rightly pointed out, atleast had the luxury of having candidates as good as they come, irrespective of political parties. Yours also had the luxury of having well-reasoned, sensible, educated independents, who could be the way out of the cynicism expressed by you towards politicians. However, by choosing to not vote, you have chosen not to participate in the democracy. As a result, you also give up the right to criticise cuz now, by criticising, you would be behaving like nothing else but that boxer, too afraid to take to the ring and hence, throwing punches in the air sitting in the balcony. Today, my head is hung in shame. All those who killed in 26/11 had thought that they by dying such a death, they had atleast awakened people to not let it happen again. However, by not making the choice, non-voters, unfortunately like you, have betrayed the true legacy that the dead wished to leave behind.

From Sejal Deshpande

May 1, 2009 1:44 AM
Priya, I wished you had made that trip to Bombay and voted as I dont think apathy can be justified by any means. But, what we need to realize that it will be some time until we see changes post 26/11..But your one vote would have increased the voter turnout today and that would have increased my friend's motivation who dint vote coz he/she dint think one vote would make a difference..so there u go..how many people's vote have u influenced? Think about it!!You could have made a difference or rather 'the' difference..You just need to realize how precious your vote is.. From what you have written, it seems that you are a politically aware person and hence if people like you make such public declarations, it will not do any good for the country..

From Rohit Pansare

May 1, 2009 8:11 AM
Congratulations you have successfully carried forward the tradition of being a part of the majority. Congratulations you are the part of 57% who did not vote..... If citizens like us can choose a holiday over our right to vote (or is it a duty?), then I don’t blame the politicians for treating their work just like a holiday. Anyways the 43% who voted either have no families or have been vacationing the whole year and took 1 day break from a whole 365 days and decided to vote......what a shame! Anyways 43% people who voted have got a new right: The right to criticize the politicians they have chosen and 57%(including you)have lost that right...so just talking!

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 8:21 AM

Anushka and Tunali, dont be rude. Sorry I let the rest of you guys (and myself) down. but im still not convinced Milind Deora deserved my vote.

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 8:23 AM

Dear concerned Mumbaikar,

I dont own a Prada swimsuit. And from what I saw on the telly yesterday, all the Prada-swimsuit-owning-types seem to have voted in full force. :)

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 9:26 AM

Thanks Shoba, I'm certainly not proud and yes I am confessing--and believe me it's tougher to do that on the Internet than in a quiet, dark church in front of a sympathetic priest..

From Famous Grouse

May 1, 2009 10:25 AM
My dad and mom-in-law came down to Bangalore (from Mangalore) just to vote on Apr 23 and left the same night. Their vote counts as Ananth Kumar and Krishna Gowda were fighting for their life in Bangalore South (like Mumbai South, a 'prestigious' seat). Priya : Your vote would have mattered.

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 10:59 AM

I hope they voted for Byre Gowda!

From Tanvi Surti

May 1, 2009 11:20 AM
Ms. Priya, You continue to comment on your apathy as it was all an amusing anecdote. Stop justifying yourself. If so many people are expressing their horror at your behaviour, there must be some reasoning behind it. This is not intended at you, but against the 57% who did not turn up. Its directed against all of you. Hope all of us have brought about some change in perspective on your behalf. Regards

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 11:32 AM

Tanvi dear, it may seem like I'm making light of the situation, but I swear I'm bleeding inside. You're right, I should have flown to Bombay and voted for Milind Deora. Sorry! While I'm praying for forgiveness, I will also pray that he doesn't lose because of people like me..

From Tanvi Surti

May 1, 2009 12:27 PM
Why are you obsessed with Milind Deora? Fine, you have made it clear you don't support him. Vote for someone else instead. Meera Sanyal? The Shiv Sena candidate? Anyone? While your tendencies towards the dramatics are definitely interesting, this is a political debate regarding a citizen's right to exercise their civic duty. So your bleeding heart aside, over 60% of the world's population does not have a right to vote. We are from the fortunate few who live in the world's biggest functioning democracy. I was in America during the 2008 Presidential Elections. People voted, even if it was to abstain. To show that they cared, to show that valued the one vote they held. Voter apathy is the poison of urban India. And then we complain that Mumbai pays 80% of the country's taxes and doesn't receive even 8 in turn.

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 12:43 PM

Vote for a banker whose bank advised Enron? And Shiv Sena? Now you are being amusing.

From MigrantInMyOwnCountry

May 1, 2009 2:02 PM
I feel so sorry for such shallow blogsters! Talk about Congress who made its own people migrant in its own country and still kept quite! Do you remember what action congress took when people were beaten on the streets of mumbai in the name of Mee Mumbaikar!! Or what have congress done for the Migrants in kashmir...have you ever visited any such camps..Talk about Milind Deora against a banker who adviced Enron...which might be the only info Deora would have provided you. Did he tell u other successful deals she made and the impact thru micro banking initiatives.Talk abt women's right when the supreme is a woman herself, when girls are being raped and murdered. What laws did they bring in? Do you remember What did they do to the caught terrorists? They can't find courage to hang them!! Get a Life 'Ms who so ever you are' and broaden your understanding of our country. i would be happy to see deora losing by ONE single vote , for you to understand how important your vote is!! For I'm a migrant in my own country, who was lathicharged for not having the name in the electoral list!Shame Congress for not being able to do consequence management to the erring officials. Maybe it was in their interest knowing we would have never voted them in.

From rk

May 1, 2009 3:45 PM
Next time, i hope you could make it to the probable MP list..I mean contesting election Independently..and not begging but demanding votes from the slumdog unmillionairesses..they will vote for you as they do not have the thinking power or the convent english education that u have..Thank god we Indians remain illiterate after 60 years of independence and keep our democracy in healthy condition as we are the only one who vote and make our leader build rome riding on our chests...Thank god we are not allowed inside the temples so that we could make someone a messiah of dalits..Thank God we are so called muslims to whom our PM says that we have the first right over the natural resources of the country and for people and community like us congress become a secular party despite killing sikhs in riots ( I hope sikhs are not minorities)..Thanks God we are those stereotyped hindus..firm God believer for whom The BJP promises to make a grand Ram temple and deceive us after taking our votes...Long live Babar to whom the congressies owe a lot..I am confused ..dont know whom to thank for the plight of the country but anyhow the star fingers do not work for Mumbai as i thought otherwise..people do react but no I am wrong as I forget We are a dead lot roaming here and there carrying a body without the soul inside..and of course writing blogs to invite comments only!!!!!!!! Jai Ho!!!!!!!

From Priya Ramani

May 1, 2009 4:42 PM

Dear RK..thank god we are so called comment-hungry bloggers who do not comprehend easily..from your favourite probable MP

From Shashwata Narain

May 1, 2009 6:17 PM
Dear Priya Ramani, My only question is, Who are you trying to punish by not voting? It's clear from your blog that you seem to be proud of being the rebel - the one who decided to walk away from the burning fire. I think you believe that not turning out to vote was some manner of extricating revenge from political parties that have "done nothing for the city." Let me assure you that your action - or lack of action, I should say - has in no way harmed the people you hoped it would harm. Rather, it's our city and it's future that you have hurt by not voting. As Tanvi has tried to make you realize, voting is a privelege with which we can make our voices not only heard (like on this blog), but also count. With all the angst that you harbour against Deora and Congress, you could have gone ahead and voted against them, for someone else - made sure that atleast on your part, they won't rise to power again. By not voting, you have ensured that there is one less vote against them. You have ensured that your vote does not prevent them from ruling Mumbai again. All you have accomplished by not voting, is indirectly voting for them. Is this the decision a smart, educated and independent-minded woman like you wants to make for her city and country? Would South-Mumbaiites, the city's smartest and most influential class, want to be held responsible for all the damage inflicted on this city by them not voting? Please don't use your words to justify your opinion - use your vote to do that. That said, it's clear now Congress, Deora and any other abhorrable party/political persona can rely on South Mumbai as their largest vote bank. By not voting, you all voted for them.

From Arvind Jadhav

May 1, 2009 9:03 PM
Sheesh typical spoiled macaulite. Our commandos do not deserve to die saving people like this priya ramani. The kind of people who make most noises in tv studios and do candle march and shout "Never Again Never Again". You voted for a party that couldn't manage to send Commandos to Mumbai for days. There is you complan boy Manmohan. They had a incompetent Home Minister and Chief Minister, they also repealed POTA. Going by Congress party argument to let Quattrochi go and repeal POTA, they should also repeal murder and rape laws and take back red corner notice against Dawood as those laws and red corner notice haven't worked. Rape and murder do take place and Dawood is still out of reach. Priya labels SS and BJP as anti Women. Priya, who supports womens reservation in parliament ? Who don't ? Priya, why do you support Milind Deora when his party under Rajiv Gandhi diluted Women's rights in the name of secularism after the Shah Bano controversy ? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shah_Bano_case 10 Janpath bankrolled ideologically halfcooked yellojournos like you hate BJP for wrongdoings of Ram Sena which fight elections against BJP. Remember Naina Sahani ? Jessica Lal ? I am sure you feel safe in Delhi under Sheela Dixit, as safe as you colleague Soumya Vishwanathan ? Take the advice of female chief minister, don't go out at night. Because Congress won't protect you. Or your rights. And please you should put a declaimer under you blog, :- "This Journalist is employed by a Media house owned by Shobhna Bhartia who is CONGRESS PARTY NOMINEE IN RAJYA SABHA".

From Melissa A. Bell

May 1, 2009 9:51 PM
By giving up her right to vote, Priya gave up her chance to influence what government will lead the country. By writing this post with the (assured) backlash of comments, she made a small step to use the public forum she's lucky to have to start a dialogue on voting. The rest of the 57% not only didn't vote, they're keeping mum. Sure, I'll happily say it's not the best choice Priya's ever made. (Trust me, as someone who has not been proud of her country's voting track record--the blood boils every time I find out someone didn't vote in the US's 2000 or 2004 election.) But at least she's admitting her fears and her regrets and starting a conversation about it. Rather than devolving into anger, shouldn't we be discussing what happened and why? Disclaimer: This Journalist is employed by a Media house owned by Shobhna Bhartia who is CONGRESS PARTY NOMINEE IN RAJYA SABHA and her editor is Priya Ramani who didn't vote. Neither of those influence my opinions much.

From Tunali

May 1, 2009 10:16 PM
Sorry, wasn't trying to be rude. But really, Murli Deora and the other majority saffron parties weren't the only ones on the list.

From ajay

May 1, 2009 11:15 PM
The Sikhs in FATA and NWFP and being lavied Zazia.... do not worry...South Mumbaikars will have to pay Zazia directly if the likes of Priya is heard ... and very soon, if the attitude remains what was demonstrated in South Mumbaiu and visible now on the blog. Though, let me remind many South Mumbaikars including Priya that some of them do Pay Zazia to Daud Bhai... or goons like Raj Thakare... Ha ha ha..... Haveli ke Seculars...... Priya types... Birla Goons.. am I adding to your popularity Priya Ramani.... I hope you do not dream of it in Roman style... or you are indulging in tacticle retreat knowing fully well that BJP is coming to power.. the misfortune of India is that people like you, considred to be the best sons and daughters of the motherland, at least so do you profess, are without any scrouples whatsoever... you pay Zazia to be in power....apologies for plainspeak......

From Soham

May 1, 2009 11:44 PM
In other words Priya is saying: "I am an idiot and proud of it"

From sukh-hoyi

May 1, 2009 11:59 PM
A black day. The Indian Air Force lost its first ever Sukhoi-30MKI this morning. Does that make any news to you Ramani...stupid...

From Arvind jadhav

May 2, 2009 1:19 AM
@Melissa A. Bell Yours are Priya's work is limited to this overpriced financial newspaper. Your opinion at best influences the rich. Same people who don't go out to vote. This tiny section of electorate doesn't matter to the the election / propaganda war room of Congress party. The likes of Sri Prakash Jaiswal and Ahmead Patel only care about what reaches masses (HT TOI Hindustan & Regional Dailies). The following are some of the tools used by Congress party media manger for affecting the opinion of such dailies :- 1)Padma Bhushan to owners 2)Padma Shree to the yellojournoes 3)Rajiv Gandhi Journalism Award to editors 4)Membership of Government Institutions of National Importance. (Very good for CV) (Here is a quiz Miss Melissa, please investigate which yellojournoes was awarded what. Hint: Start with Editors) But this can only change the opinion. If the people in power mean business (Propaganda/Brainwashing) they have following tools :- 1)Express license to News Channel. 2)Express license to Radio channel. But how are poor yellojournoes going to afford the expensive infrastructure necessary for News Channels, we have swiss bank accounts to rescue. No wonder that numerous news channels have cropped up even when the old ones like NDTV make losses year after year.That is the magic of cheap loan from 10 Janpath. The YelloJournoes can afford to stay afloat not matter what. If you still disagree, then ask MJ Akbar whether Indian Media is influenced by the people in power or not. People lower in pegging start to develop a New Age Indian disease common among the macaulayites, called pseudo-secularism. The ideology that the editors and the owners sell for money rubs off to those down below them. And they start to parrot the same lines "BJP eeevil, Hindus baad, Sonia goooood" (For free). Those who see through this drivel, they have no option but to go with the flow, otherwise they end up getting fired like MJ Akbar. Yes i hate the media, yes i am angry. I am more angry at the journalists than the politicians who own media houses. Because of the holier than thou attitude because they use the TV Radio Newspapers to brainwash masses every day. Why had the discussion, we had it after the Mumbai Attack. The likes of Barkha and Slurdesai were busy deflecting anger from their financiers (MMS, Mainos etc). They managed to make the Indians believe that the people in powers aren't responsible, every one is. So if every ones is responsible, then why vote out the people who repealed the Anti Terror laws and managed to not spend 80% of money allocated for defense purpose. Looking at the record low turnout, seems to me they were very successful. In election time sycophants within the media are busy eulogizing Rahul and comparing the facial features of Priyanka with Indira's, while real issues like farmer suicides, electricity and water shortage, corruption and poor infrastructure is taking back seat. Media won't talk about this because that will make Congress look bad. They will show it if that makes the opposition look bad. They will show what Varun Gandhi said but not what D Srinivas said(Would have made Congress look communal, can't do that). Any wonder that we have maximum deaths due to terrorism, malnourished children, suicides in whole world ?. Media has become roadblock for freedom and development as they will hide the real issues to help the people in power. Media has to go. We have anger, it may get channelized into something worthwhile and hopefully someday we will talk about yellojournoes as some kind of dinosaurs. First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.

From Priya Ramani

May 2, 2009 9:58 AM
Tunali and Shahswata, you guys are right. Am not proud...knew i would be slapped repeatedly for this post, but as Gandhiji said...The rest of you, i dont engage with media bashers and right wing ranters

From Ashu

May 2, 2009 10:18 AM
thanks u didn't vote.... u saved the mumbai not voting to congress

From Soham

May 2, 2009 11:56 AM
@Melissa You salvaged a lot more respect from me for including that disclaimer.

From Pawan Gulani

May 2, 2009 12:19 PM
I completely empathise with Priya on what she is going through. The tribe of people like her and I constantly fight with ourselves inside with this question to vote or not to vote. Rather the electoral process is a once in a while dillemna. The amount of questions that our society throws at me completely completely overwhelms us. We can ofcourse make a small change and shape a few lives which most of us are doing but honestly somehow the country seems to be a lost cause. One party being worse than the other. There is a lot of good work happening by some news channels, some newspapers, some people. I personally know so many people who are fighting the system and living with it or shall I say despite of it. They continue to be dogged down by the whole top heavy Indian politics. This is not to say that all things government are corrupt and inefficient. Some of the best best practices in corporates and some of my service fables are with the governent departments. Its only a select few who has let the whole nation down and it's against those I choose not to vote .

From nandu

May 3, 2009 2:02 AM
Is it Pawn Gulani or Parwez Gilani...???? Ha....

From Why Have Voter Registration Campaigns Not Increased Voter Turnout in the 2009 Indian Lok Sabha Elections? | Gauravonomics Blog

May 3, 2009 12:08 PM

Pingback from  Why Have Voter Registration Campaigns Not Increased Voter Turnout in the 2009 Indian Lok Sabha Elections?  | Gauravonomics Blog

From Vipin

May 4, 2009 12:24 PM
Good..

From Salil

May 4, 2009 1:24 PM
hmm Priya... You won't vote for a candidate whose bank advised Enron - fair enough, even though it was one of the banks, and not the only bank to do so. But you don't mind voting for another candidate whose party approved the Enron deal. Trying to figure it out :) - Salil (who writes a column for Lounge which Priya and her colleagues edit, so there!)

From Priya Ramani

May 4, 2009 1:56 PM

good point. not sure which is worst, the government that cleared the project, the government that cancelled it, then cleared it again, or the bank who was with it to the gory end--i should have voted for the other independent, mona patel shah. Everyone's equally pathetic, though shiv sena candidate rawale certainly has the largest number of pending cases...we're talking sections 143, 147, 341, 150 & 174 Indian Railway Act ,  37(3) 136 of Bombay Police Act, 37(1) r.w 136 of B.P Act,  37 (3) r.w 135 of B.P.Act, 33 (R),37(1)(D), 37(3) 135 of B.P.Act

From Priya Ramani

May 4, 2009 2:01 PM

good point. not sure which is worst, the government that cleared the project, the government that cancelled it, then cleared it again, or the bank who was with it to the gory end--i should have voted for the other independent, mona patel shah. Everyone's equally pathetic, though shiv sena candidate rawale certainly has the largest number of pending cases...we're talking sections 143, 147, 341, 150 & 174 Indian Railway Act ,  37(3) 136 of Bombay Police Act, 37(1) r.w 136 of B.P Act,  37 (3) r.w 135 of B.P.Act, 33 (R),37(1)(D), 37(3) 135 of B.P.Act

From nevermind

May 4, 2009 6:07 PM
Priya, to write this took a particular kind of courage. One that is rare in India. Respect.

From nevermind

May 4, 2009 6:08 PM
Priya, to write this took a particular kind of courage. One that is rare in India. Respect.

From Priya Ramani

May 4, 2009 8:58 PM

THANK YOU nevermind sir/maam

From KJ

May 5, 2009 2:24 AM
Ah, so you found a stooge that actually appreciated your blog (twice in a hurry) and you are quick to thank him/her....and you don't have a single argument to all the other extremely valid comments..some courage indeed

From Priya Ramani

May 5, 2009 10:09 AM

KJ, THANK YOU for reading my blog so carefully and tracking my every word.

From Seriously?

May 5, 2009 10:00 PM
The entire premise on which you claim you didn't vote being ridiculous as it is, you seem to defend your case with utterly stupid arguments like 'a candidate whose bank advised Enron' and 'the chief minister took RGV to the hotel' (the CM quit after that btw)... oozing with Nationalism are you? Thats exactly why you have to exercise your vote you confused cow !!! Hey Dave Letterman writers, you reading? I nominate this blog to the "Top Ten List of Idiotic WebNeters" :)) And Priya, I have a feeling although you personally didn't vote, I'am sure someone did it for you as a proxy (hey they do that ya know) ..and maybe that proxy actually went to Shiv Sena ..thanks for not voting

From Priya Ramani

May 6, 2009 9:55 AM

Seriously, at least i write under my real name.

From Raj

May 6, 2009 3:31 PM
I understand why you could not vote, but as has been pointed out earlier by many readers, your bias against some of the candidates perplexes me. I have worked with Meera Sanyal and she was respected and loved by everybody at work.She is honest, hard working,intelligent, charismatic and extremely approachable. I am a bit surprised that you did not take time to really know the candidates from your beloved South Mumbai!!

From Priya Ramani

May 6, 2009 6:17 PM

Raj, election choices are by definition biased. Or how would we decide who to vote for? Anyway, got this email forward from a friend...

10 reasons why Malabar Hill turn out was so low:

1 Clashed with Salsa class.

2.Election whites not dry cleaned.

3.No candidate a hottie.

4.Tony Jethmalani contesting from suburbs, ugh.

5 No valet parking at booth.

6.Spotted servant in queue ahead of us.

7. Driver didn't come.

8. No party tackling real issues e.g. reduce Gold Gym rates

9. No home delivery!

10 Elections over dude! Obama won.

From Seriously again..

May 7, 2009 12:46 AM
Go ahead and bask in the glory of 'using your real name'...I'am certain most of the readers could care less about your real name...what with a zillion idiots blogging around on the web...it is the content of your blogs that matters..and even worse since you use a popular news website to put this crap out there as a paid service.. Malabar hills is not Beverly hills and it never will be...so you guys should not even try..like the saying goes 'You can put lipstick on a pig, but it is still a pig' (oops, didn't Obama get into trouble for using that against another bimbo....)..well whatever. So, the next time you complain about 'dirty, grimy, overcrowded, overworked Mumbai ', I would like to quote Wesley Gibson's very last lines from the movie 'Wanted' ...I can't really type it here..but I think you should get my point... Please continue making a fool of yourself and livemint... Btw, you can address me as Morpheus...its a proxy, similar to the one that voted on your behalf !

From Priya

May 7, 2009 10:35 AM
There's no glory in being a journalist in India, especially with articulate/abusive readers such as yourself.

From shamith

May 7, 2009 11:43 AM
What happened to poor bollywood characters!!! Listen -- Abhi's beard has got some cob-webs. Could you please care on using your wonderful words to clear those!!

From Gaurav kale

May 7, 2009 6:37 PM
Am surprised that you are even answering to so much of thrash here. It may never come to an end this way.

From Morpheus

May 7, 2009 7:49 PM
Priya, thanks for the compliment..and please don't insult the word 'journalist' by calling yourself that..i have read your other blogs/articles and you come out just like any other attention starved blogger trying to increase your internet footprint at any cost with the lack of ethics/values of true journalism...I recommend the latest Russel Crowe movie 'State of Play' to psuedo journos such as yourself ... A wise guy once said "Whatever you do, don’t congratulate yourself too much. You’re not that good." Peace

From Eswaran Krishnan

May 8, 2009 8:46 AM
Hi Priya, The Mumbai roads that we drive on, the numerous flyovers that we use so very conveniently, the largely uninterrupted power supply that we enjoy, the fantastic public transport system (trains and buses) at our service--though this one may not be a SoBo concern-- the list of positives is endless. The debate can be whether these facilities are there because of politicians or in spite of them, but we cannot deny the numnerous luxuries that we enjoy and take for granted and keep feeling they are inferior because we end up comparing our city/cities with a Shanghai, Singapore, Tokyo, or a Paris. As far as candidates go, if we are not willing to throw out hats into the ring, then we must take the effort to research and select the least evil of the lot. You did not want to vote, fair enough. Your life, your choice. But justifying that in a public forum and conveniently attributing your reasoning to be that of the large majority is unfair. I do not live in SoBo, but I am educated, and I did go out at 7 am on April 30 and cast my vote. We can either be the catalyst for change or be part of a larger change that is happening around us. No point in talking about change and doing nothing to help bring about that change. My arguments are neither against your freedom to write nor are in support of any political party. I am just looking at things from a positve perspective as I always do, and when I do that, I end up appreciating the good things that a large many of us tend to overlook. But they this is my view, and every other person is entitled to his or her own. Regards, Eswaran

From kalyan

May 8, 2009 2:33 PM
where one thinks the options are all bad, then 49o(3) is a good tool - the right to record a 'no vote'. it is a great signalling tool to all parties that there is a category of voters who are willing to vote but for only better candidates - a tool to independents like meera/gopinath to pitch from that constitutency. and if the concern is that it wont lead to a change in this elections round, then who are u kidding - by voting another devil, do you make ur life any better for the next 5 years ?? agreed that 49o(3) cud be much more powerful if all that the EC is fighting for is agreed - cancelling voting if 49o(3) votes exceed a certain margin - nevertheless, even now i think its a great tool for all those who have abstained from voting all these days with the crib that there is nobody good to vote !

From Priya Ramani

May 8, 2009 4:03 PM

Thanks eswaran, and agree kalyan

From Aman Trehan

May 9, 2009 12:07 AM
bloody hypocrites - thats what you are. You guys just don't care.You just want to to be happy in your cocoon and feel good about life. Its just sad to hear you give justification about not voting which is totally pointless.Due to some crazy random incident (RGV touring Oberoi), you decide to write off a national party - gimmme a break! I dont think you even understand the larger issue here and are too whimsical. I worked with this team of guys who have a dream and they are passionately working towards it - the one billion votes movement.talking about Janagraha - the NGO from Bangalore.And I know they are going to bring about this change , though it will take some time - a few years maybe. their vision is to make the whole business of governance & politics an important part of citizen's daily life - awaken him , enlighten him & empower him with information.That will surely definitely improve the quality of democracy in this country, not this crappy piece of editorial from a whimsical irresponsible citizen. Sadly , You and your townies just missed the vital point. Plz dont write such useless articles which could be detrimental to this democratic process where in a lot of ppl become complacent using excuses given by you and abstain from voting.they do no good at all. Aman Trehan. New Delhi.

From Ajit

May 9, 2009 1:38 AM
I was quite entertained by this post on the blog and i was more entertained by the comments.. I appreciate Madam Priya Ramani decision which is rather personal and i think most of commentators on the blog have no right to question that. But what intrigues me more is the voyeurism in this whole issue. i-voted-for-milind types of comment do violates the basic tenets of "secret ballot". Remember old doordarshan commercial during election which used to say "Aapka matdan gupt rakhe" :D anyways i dont have any issues with Mrs Ramani exhibition of her blatant support for Mr Milind Deora.but what surely perplxes me that she has reasons for not voting Banker who advised Enron and the party who has mandir on their manifesto but she can vote for man who only achievement is that he was that one sperm cell whcih out smarted million sperm cells of Mr murli deora. Quite an achievement indeed. He deserves a vote .. :) moreover i was also impressed by Mrs ramani's knowldege on political parties and she has quite an opinion on them. but people who frame thier opinion on watching ticker of MTV can be quite entertaing. Mrs Ramani was quite entertaining indeed. i would really advise her to go through manifestos of all the political parties For example, apart from mandir BJP has a dedicated manifesto for India's IT policy and Renewable Energy Policy.. i'm sure they dont get flashed in tabloids they lady prefers to read. Anyways its not about which party is right or which party is wrong. But what concerns how people like Ms Ramani arrive at conclusions and how they frame the opinion of million others. P.S. Journos have greater responsibilities but i 'm sorry to say that they have dissappointed me more than the wretched politicians

From Deepak Rao

May 9, 2009 1:42 PM
Morpheus/Seriously/whatever: You're quite a snivelling little coward aren't you? At least Priya has the guts to blog under her name -- whether you agree with her or not -- and take your abuse. Let me guess, you live at home with your mama and hide behind her saree, right? Mama, mama, that girl is blogging. Can I abuse her? Yes bete, you're a good Indian boy. Please spit and abuse, it's our culture. Your daddy will protect you. Ah, don't bother to respond. Defintely not coming back to check the froth on your mouth and the pole up your behind.

From Morpheus/Seriously/whatever

May 9, 2009 6:53 PM
Bravo Deepak Rao, Bravo ! Your mommy and daddy must be so proud that you came to the rescue of a poor little girl-blogger from the likes of abusive readers myself. And you did it using your 'real' name - wow ! I'am sure they have chocolates and other goodies lined up for you...go get 'em tiger..and let me go hide behind mama's saree, coz I'am soooo scared now And Mr. Deepak Rao now that you have had your 'real' name indexed by Google, please clean the froth from YOUR mouth and pull the pole out from YOUR behind and post your opinion on the main blog as opposed to responding to comments meant for the writer (unless ofcourse you both are the same) ... Eagerly awaiting some more culture lessons from you... - Morpheus

From oxy

May 12, 2009 9:03 PM
have lost all respect for your writing as wll as that of your prestigious newspaper.. first you write such a piece of shit, and then you go on to defend it when some people ask questions on your actions!!

From District 9 + Mint Lounge = Horrible Horrible « Off The Record | Pratik Arora

September 19, 2009 8:43 PM

Pingback from  District 9 + Mint Lounge = Horrible Horrible « Off The Record | Pratik Arora

POST YOUR COMMENT

:
(required)
 
Email Address
(required)
   
(optional)
(HTML not allowed)