Where does arsenic in West Bengal water come from? - Lab Rats

Where does arsenic in West Bengal water come from?

Seema Singh - Thursday, July 24, 2008 3:08 PM

Unsafe levels of arsenic in drinking water are common in several parts of West Bengal and other south-east Asian regions. The levels are so high that they are now impacting staple crops like rice.

Where does this arsenic come from? It is agreed that arsenic contamination in the ground water of south and south-east Asia is a consequence of arsenic dissolving from naturally deposited sediments (eroded Himalayan sediments). But the location within the sediment profile, the time period, and the effect of hydrology on arsenic release are not quite known, even though this information is crucial for planning remedial responses and for estimating future arsenic concentrations.

One of the puzzling issues for researchers has been the localization of arsenic within sedimentary aquifers. In other words, it's been difficult to explain how wells with severely contaminated water can have safe wells (with no arsenic contamination) just within 10 metres.

In a first ever study tracing the source of contamination, authors from Stanford and Boise State (Idaho) Universities and Resource Development International in Cambodia report in today's Nature that they studied the minimally disturbed Mekong delta in Cambodia ( in contrast, Ganges and other Asian river deltas have experienced intensive agricultural practices) and found that arsenic is released from near-surface, river-derived sediments and transported through the underlying aquifer back to the river.

Due to similarities in geologic deposition, aquifer source rock and hydrology, the authors claim their results provide a model for understanding pre-disturbance conditions of other deltas in Asia, including the Ganges.

That is, by using this model groundwater researchers and managers can discover where does arsenic in the Gangetic delta aquifer come from and how anthropogenic (or man-made) factors like groundwater pumping for irrigation, changes in agricultural practices, etc. will impact arsenic in the groundwater.

"Moreover, these results suggest a shift in the appropriate model from dominant geochemical control towards substantial hydrologic control of arsenic in southeast Asian ground water," they say. Clearly, this could also effect a shift in health management of tens of millions of people in the region.

 

 

 

Share this post: email it! | del.icio.us! | digg it! | newsVine!

From Suvrat

July 26, 2008 2:35 PM
Nice concise commentary. I am not sure of the claim that this Nature study is the first ever to trace the source of contamination. This study done last year in the Bengal basin (Ganges Brahmaputra delta sediments) came to similar conclusions. The arsenic is trapped in organic rich deltaic sediments, the concentrations are correlated to surface elevation and local topography and hydro-geologic conditions controls its release in the groundwater.

From Seema Singh

July 26, 2008 6:34 PM

Thanks for your comments. You have an interesting and informative blog on earth sciences.

As for this paper, I think the claim they make is about their grip on the processes that control passage of arsenic release into pore water, which so far has remained unclear. And this they claim makes it a useful model to study other deltaic regions. What you are referring to in WB study is indeed right, but its one particular study.

From Dimitri

August 7, 2008 7:48 PM
Is there any detailed information on arsenic and iron concentration in Jalpaiguri, Cooch Behar, Parulia, Bankura and Paschim Medinipur?

From seema

August 11, 2008 8:39 PM
Why don't you check with Suvrat (msg posted above)? Meanwhile, I'll look for any relevant information.

From Zubair Adhami

October 24, 2008 8:55 PM
I am incharge of drinking water quality of Kashmir PHE department Govt. of J&K We have recently discoverd Arsenic in our ground water in Kashmir, we are using strip test kit from Germany.Level of Arsenic detected is 0.1mg/l How do i confirm things. we are running a small lab here. can i recommend this water for drinking.or do i wait for your guidance thanks & regards Er. Zubair PHE department Kashmir

POST YOUR COMMENT

:
(required)
 
Email Address
(required)
   
(optional)
(HTML not allowed)