Too few sarees at the IPL... It's just not cricket! - Life etc...

Too few sarees at the IPL... It's just not cricket!

Malavika R. Banerjee - Sunday, August 16, 2009 8:30 AM

Can a woman go watch an IPL game in a saree? Can she dress like that and sit in the Wankhede Stadium press box? The teams have uniforms, the cheerleaders are uniformly cheering. No surprise then, that uniformity has spread to the galleries as well. You could be a generous size 16, or somebody who has never really felt her best in the tee and jeans look, but when it's match day, there is no alternative.

Two unrelated incidents occurred last week that got me thinking about Indian women in sports-related spheres of work and women who turn up for a game. The first was a response to my piece on Abhinav Bindra which said: ‘You look like a pale Aunty.' This has been the cause of much mirth among my friends (yes, yes, they are not very loyal) but not enough for me to go for that image makeover. All I can say to this observation is: Dude, guess what... I am a pale Aunty. But what does that have to do with my writing on sport?

The second incident was when I chanced upon a photograph of Sharmila Tagore with M.A.K. Pataudi, watching a game in England. Just do an image search for Sharmila and Pataudi and you will see it - believe me it's a stunning image which I would have used here, but could not since it's credited as unknown. They are sitting on a grass mound near a quaint scoreboard, and Pataudi is all togged up in a suit and Sharmila is the picture of poise in a saree and jhumkas. We keep looking for an Indian equivalent of Posh and Becks, but Bollywood met cricket long before EPL met British pop. Note that Sharmila is looking this glamorous in a chiffon saree. Remember, this is an actor who thought nothing of wearing a bikini for An Evening in Paris, and who was extremely comfortable in Western wear unlike most of her contemporaries. Yet here she is in England, wearing a saree and looking like a million bucks.

There was a certain construct of what a woman who works with sport should look like, around a decade ago and it has not entirely disappeared. She should be androgynous, sporty to look at, tom-boyish in attitude and most certainly be uncomfortable in anything feminine or ‘traditional'. The assumption being that if you are dealing with sports (boys' zone basically), you should have spent your youth scraping your knees rather than filing your nails. There have been times when I have felt like a manicured misfit.

What's worse, these parameters don't hold for men, and they come in all forms ranging from six-pack to beer belly - a fact that can be borne out by a glance across the press box at any sports venue.

Today, when all things Western are upheld as "hi-fashion", even when it does not really suit our climate or the way some of us are made, women who want to watch sports are also pressured into assuming a certain sporty look when they go to the grounds. I feel troubled when I see these women tugging at their tees and looking ill at ease. God knows that Indian stadiums are challenging enough, for us to not challenge ourselves further with image issues. During the IPL I saw many women uncomfortably slouched in team t-shirts, clearly out of sorts. Comfort is of the essence at all times while watching a game, and style and sophistication are not achieved only in Western wear. Many of us look better, feel better in Indian clothes and there is no need to feel less smart in a salwar-kameez than in a shirt and trousers. The drawstring comfort of salwars in muggy Kolkata is incomparable and I cannot figure out why women feel the need to wear those Lycra-mixed business suits when they can be crisp as a toast in a cotton kurta.

Live and let live, and everyone must wear what they want to - no question about that. However, a corollary to that is that we must not be brainwashed into wanting to wear something only because it's behenji (or pale aunty!) not to. In trying to be fashionistas we must not become fashion victims.

Today we have a generation that thinks it's uber cool to be uncomfortable in a saree, and that West is best for all things sartorial. I would ask them to draw inspiration from Sharmila Tagore, who straddled both styles with ease, four decades ago. We often forget: to be a global citizen, one has to be confident and proud of one's own identity and culture. If sports is celebrated as a meeting ground for various cultures, why should we be embarrassed to showcase our Indianness?

Share this post: email it! | del.icio.us! | digg it! | newsVine!

From Karpagam

August 16, 2009 2:26 PM
I endorse your views completely. People have long forgotten that more than wearing 'whats in' one should wear what 'makes you feel good and poised. These it is modern to say 'its so difficult to wear a saree! how do you do it'. Till the previous generation, every woman was living and sleeping in sarees, climbing buses, going to colleges, work etc. This plight has got to do with people searching to establish an identity for themselves, getting included by a pseudo society that models itself on what they see in films. You asking to look at Sharmila is like asking to look at ones grandparents. They would rather look at Soha,Priyanka, Aishwarya, Genelia etc. While mimicking the screen idols, forgetting they do not sport the same body that the stars do. Talking of IPL, did you not notice Mrs. Ambani sporting her tee shirt and having knocked off a few pounds to look elegant?

From rohan shankar

August 17, 2009 11:52 AM
I googled the picture and Sharmila looks jaw-dropping gorgeous... they sure don't make them like they used to. Whether we like it or not, dressing in a global manner is one of the yardsticks of being progressive. We don't see the Japanese in Kimonos and we don't see the chinese in their traditional garb. The world is shrinking and there is no place for sentimentality. True, the saree is an elegant dress and most Indian women look their best in it, but in a more fitness-conscious society, it's more likely that women will wear something more trendy. Now it's up to our filmi fashionistas to reinvent the saree as an 'it' garment, and then you will see the women go the whole seven, or is it, nine yards!!

From Rashi

August 18, 2009 8:42 AM
As someone who visits India annually these days, I find it amazing how the saree has disappeared from the streets of Mumbai. There are hardly any women in South Mumbai in kurtas, so sarees are not even thought of. An IPL game is a far-off thought,I don't even see women who need to be smartly dressed to work considering Saree as an option. Everybody is in trousers and tops, and only the 50-plus top of the line bankers patronise it. As for the pale aunty look, in a cosmetic-crazy society that too is becoming a rare sight.

From Vandana

August 18, 2009 10:48 AM
Very original topic and well argued.I haven t read too many things about how women sport watchers should look. I guess there s a difference between women watching sport and those participating.For participants it is obvious they should wear sporty clothes. But logically there is no need for the spectator to do the same. They should just wear what they feel comfortable. Perhaps they force themselves into ill fitting sporty wear to fit in with the environment. Just like jeans would look out of place in a traditional wedding ceremony or shorts would look weird while on a pilgrimage no matter how comfortable the wearer feels in them. Similarly..it s a question of blending in with the mileu, I guess.

From Sudha

August 18, 2009 12:45 PM
Next you will quote examples of how ladies wore saris and played tennis or badminton and looked oh so elegant. In fact I would advocate that these ladies picked up the guts to wear shorts, tees and the like to sporting events and in the process spent some time shaping up and starting to look fit. I also would recommend they not cover up with shapeless salwar kameezes and saris. If the sari is being relegated to party wear - so be it. How many men walk around wearing pyjamas and lungis anyway!

From pratiba

August 18, 2009 1:03 PM
Hi,Ms.Malavika R.Benerjee... I agree with u in the above report..many think the same way,as u mentioned.yes,we can be very confident in our indian attire..n i think we indians have great variety n options in presenting ourselves...ofcourse cant deny the comfort in western wear...but it should'nt become obsession to people who r not used to them.....anyways...wonderful article...n gud that u quoted abhinav bindra n his statement on ur attire..i feel such articles help people who want to come out of closed feelings n thoughts....once again....great reading it....bye...

From pratiba

August 18, 2009 1:04 PM
Hi,Ms.Malavika R.Benerjee... I agree with u in the above report..many think the same way,as u mentioned.yes,we can be very confident in our indian attire..n i think we indians have great variety n options in presenting ourselves...ofcourse cant deny the comfort in western wear...but it should'nt become obsession to people who r not used to them.....anyways...wonderful article...n gud that u quoted abhinav bindra n his statement on ur attire..i feel such articles help people who want to come out of closed feelings n thoughts....once again....great reading it....bye...

From Malavika R. Banerjee

August 19, 2009 5:34 PM
I see each reaction has a different take on my views, which is just the way it should be. Karpagam rightly mentions that Sharmila Tagore cannot be held up as an icon for today's youngsters. However, I think we could learn from her ability to blend east and west effortlessly. Rohan and Rashi are also right in observing that sarees are disappearing from the streets, and a cricket stadium is only an extension of that phenomenon. As for Vandy, there is a thin line between wanting to blend in and being pressured to wear something that we are not comfortable in. Sudha, I don't recall mentioning what sportswomen wear so please rest assured, I won't expect Saina to turn up at the other side of the net in a saree any time soon. And I hope we don't start measuring guts and courage by our ability to tuck in our tummies and get into those skinny jeans.

POST YOUR COMMENT

:
(required)
 
Email Address
(required)
   
(optional)
(HTML not allowed)