Insane waste of tax payers money to debate "reasonable" restrictions on mobile phones - A Romantic Realist

Insane waste of tax payers money to debate "reasonable" restrictions on mobile phones

Raju Narisetti - Monday, August 18, 2008 7:03 PM

Not too many people would have noticed a Parliament of India ad on Page 13 of Hindustan Times' New Delhi edition on 18 August. It turns out that the Committee on Petitions of the Rajya Sabha has decided to consider what it dubs as a petition for "Imposition of Reasonable Restrictions on Use of Mobile Phones." Want to know what some of these "reasonable" restrictions are? How about:

1) Jammers/decoders should be installed in the premises of educational institutions so that calls on mobile phones could be restricted. Only phone calls for administrative purposes should be allowed. It should be made an offence to receive or make private/personal phone calls on the campus through a private mobile phone and the violator should be prosecuted.

2) The cellular phone companies should instal apparatus which will not allow the handsets to function on the roads or while driving. Special areas may be erected where mobile phone calls may be made or received. Using mobile phone while driving should be made a non-bailable and a non-compoundable offence.

3) A law should be enacted prohibiting use of mobile phones or carrying it to places of worship, cremation grounds and burial places.

4) Use of mobile phones or carrying it in public offices by persons should be prohibited by law. Making or receiving private or personal calls during office hours should be an offence punishable with imprisonment and fine. Receiving and making official calls may, however, be exempted from the proposed restriction.

5) There should be a ban on mobile phones fitted with cameras for the safety of women, as it violates their privacy. Owning or possessing of mobile phones fitted with camera for professional needs may be allowed subject to the person obtaining a licence from the concerned authority.

I swear on my Blackberry I am not making all this up. But I can't decide who is more insane--the petitioner of these mostly impractical and mostly unimplementable (thankfully) ideas or our Parliamentarians, led by Committee Chair M Venkaiah Naidu of the Bharatiya Janata Party, who want to waste their time and our tax money on such petitions.

If you want to tell the Committee what you think of all this, do write to J. Sundriyal, joint director of the Rajya Sabha Secretariat at sundrial@sansad.nic.in by September 15, the deadline for the Committee to receive written memos on this weighty issue. Or, better yet, make a statement by using your mobile phone to tell him what you really think of this petition by calling him at 011-23034541.  

Share this post: email it! | del.icio.us! | digg it! | newsVine!

From Aroop

August 21, 2008 9:42 AM
Its not the first time that such impractical ideas have come up. I remember the idea of making id cards compulsory for every living being (and perhaps their pets too) in Delhi. The id card had to belong to Delhi, so outsiders should better carry their passports! The mobile phone with its features is a part of the daily lives of many individuals. Its a shame that such parliamentarians do not understand the reality, and go ahead with such proposals that waste money and time! Are we going back in time??

From Lubna Kably

August 21, 2008 10:34 PM
Wow, and I thought that only tax laws were "reasonable". The use taxes are put to, is even "more reasonable". The only part which is a bit sane is trying to deter use of mobile phones while driving.

From Raju Narisetti

August 23, 2008 4:09 PM

Good to see that The Economic Times has discovered this story on 23 August. Even if there is no culture of acknowledging other papers for breaking news first (in this case this blog and the front page of Hindustan Times a day later on 19 August), at least important stories aren't being ignored because someone else has it first. The Indian newspaper culture of putting the paper's ego ahead of readers doesn't serve either the institution or readers.

economictimes.indiatimes.com/.../3394744.cms

From Vivek Verma

August 24, 2008 9:42 PM
I have a suggestion on how this can be carried out. Mr Venkaiah Naidu can schedule a visit with a bunch of politicians on some 100 countries around the globe to study what they are doing to curb the use of mobile phones. And submit a report to the Parliament in 2-3 years. By then India will have crossed 500 million subcribers and mobile phones will have become a nuisance anyways. Mr. Narisetti, why don't you use your good offices to make that suggestion to Mr. Naidu?

From Raju Narisetti

August 25, 2008 8:10 AM

Vivek--My only fear would be Mr. Naidu will miss the irony and take up the suggestion and some 15 MPs will tour the world at your and my tax expense!

From rassimoo

September 2, 2008 6:06 PM
Best Hotels of 5 star hotel istanbul hotel and airport hotels istanbul, which lists more than 150 quality 4 & 3 star hotels istanbul, special hotels

POST YOUR COMMENT

:
(required)
 
Email Address
(required)
   
(optional)
(HTML not allowed)