What, No Load !!! What, No Load ???
Harish Rao -
Sunday, June 21, 2009 5:08 PM
SEBI has just decreed that Mutual Funds in India will not charge a load. And many Financial Advisors have concluded that the epitaph in their tombstone has just been carved in granite by SEBI.
Having keenly observed and been an enthusiastic participant in the Investment Advisory business for more than a decade, there are two truths I firmly believe in.
-
1. The Mutual Fund is the greatest financial product in India today. It has the ability to create and preserve the wealth of millions of Indians. It is truly egalitarian, convenient and has a tremendous sense of integrity in its design. It is also fortunate in having SEBI as its regulator. And SEBI has done a terrific job.
- 2. The Mutual Fund Agent / Advisor has rendered maximum service and exerted the greatest of efforts in evangelizing mutual funds, despite the vagaries of the stock and money markets. The Mutual Fund Agent / Advisor - be it individual or institutional - has often received compensation that is a fraction of what their insurance counterparts have received.
So what is the fuss all about ? It's about the collision between the regulator and the distributor. For those not aware of what has happened, here is a three sentence gist : The regulator has abolished the entry load in Mutual Funds. This entry load (usually around 2.25%) was used to compensate the distributor. So now, investors get to enter for free, but will have to compensate their distributor with a separate cheque, at a rate of their discretion.
(Click Here for an earlier article on Variable Loads).
SEBI has clearly disrupted a perfectly well oiled business model. My sympathies with the distribution fraternity. This is a HUGE change. But SEBI must be having valid reasons for that. You bet. Foremost amongst them : Churning. Misselling. Skewed compensation to various distributors.
Do all distributors fall in this unsavoury category. Never. Just an unscrupulous few.
The Road Ahead
At this point in time, the path ahead seems unclear. Distributors have to shift to a fee based model and will have to make clients aware of their value. The clients on their part will have to realize that there is no such thing as a free lunch.
As I had said earlier, Mutual Funds are one of the finest financial products. I only hope that the best distributors continue their relentless pursuit of giving the finest advice and service. I also hope that some clients get over their mentality of discounting financial advice or trying to extract information for free. Every advisor should be adequately compensated for the energy and effort expended as well as education and counsel imparted. Not compensating an advisor satisfactorily would be the most unfair thing. But the moot point : Just what is fair? 1%, 3%, 5% or 0.1%
Knee-jerk Reactions
Some distributors I have met have predictably announced the death of the mutual fund industry. That is not going to happen. The destination remains the same. The routes have changed. All industries have to keep re-working the dynamics. Just ask Shah Rukh and Aamir. They have had to kiss and make-up so that Bollywood could do business with the Multiplexes.
What should the AMC do ?
The Asset Management Companies must recognize that this is a game changer. And not all distributors are equipped to handle the change. AMCs must initiate a dialogue with distributors and also inform their clients about SEBIs new rule. Clients must be made aware about the services they can expect from advisors and the necessity of engaging good advisors to achieve financial objectives.
AMCs also realize that they cannot afford disintermediation and that a robust channel is necessary to grow AUMs. Hopefully SEBI realizes this too.
As a strong votary of the Mutual Fund business, I hope SEBI, AMCs and Distributors work together to build a fantastic Asset Management industry in India. All the very best, everyone.